Andrew is currently the girls' head coach at Lancaster Mennonite High School. Andrew played his college soccer at Millersville University from 2001-2003. Andrew then transferred to West Chester University where he graduated with a B.S. in Health and Physical Education in 2006. Since then, he has been teaching elementary P.E. in the Columbia Borough School District. Before taking over the girls program at LMH, Andrew worked as the boys and girls assistant coach/JV coach there. Andrew began coaching with Penn Legacy in 2013.